A Long Term Problem

By Kevin Shannahan/Opinion

KevinShannahan2017

Things are not always as they appear. The Natchitoches Parish School system might have a body teaching, or at least present, in each classroom, but that is not the whole story. The person teaching your child might not be a certified teacher. He or she might not even have a 4 year degree. He or she might not have a degree in the subject being taught.

The Natchitoches schools employ a depressingly large number of long term substitute teachers, 62 at last count. This is alarming on several levels. Firstly, long term substitutes hide the problem. On the surface, all appears well. After all, there is a teacher in every classroom. A parent might not even be aware that their child is being taught by a non-certified teacher. The use of long term substitutes enables the district to hide the underlying problem-that the school district is unable to attract and retain enough quality teachers to fully staff the schools. This has been the case for years!

Secondly, this burden is not being equitably borne by all of the parish’s schools. If we must employ long term substitutes of dubious quality, it is a moral imperative that the burden be borne equally by each school. No school and no child should have a greater or lesser chance of having a non-certified teacher because of where his or her school is located.


Let me be perfectly clear here. I think there is a base level of intellectual capacity needed to be a schoolteacher. If a retired engineer, lawyer or college professor does not have a teaching certificate, I am not overly worried. The Louisiana School for Math, Science and the Arts seems to do rather nicely with an almost entirely uncertified faculty. On the other hand, if a person is a long term substitute because he or she cannot pass the Praxis tests, I am quite concerned. If they have failed the tests more than once, I think they need to do something else for a living. If you cannot pass the Praxis, you have no business being a schoolteacher-period. I don’t care if you claim you “are not a good test taker.” Would you accept that excuse from a physician, nurse, engineer or lawyer, all of whom have to pass licensing exams in order to practice?

I taught at a desperately poor school in rural north Louisiana after leaving the Air Force. I had a college degree, but not a teaching certificate, so I had to pass the National Teacher Exam (NTE) by the end of my first year, or I wouldn’t have a second one. The NTE was, over the years, replaced by the jazzier sounding Praxis Exams, both by the same company.

The NTE Core Battery I took was not rocket science and the Praxis seems no more difficult. Any of the Regents Exams I had to pass to leave high school in NY were far more challenging. How someone supposedly in possession of a 4 year degree cannot easily pass them is quite beyond me. This matters. That our parish employs anyone as a teacher who cannot pass these rudimentary tests should alarm every parent and citizen in our community. It is a critical measure of our school systems quality and one of the most amenable to correction.

The Natchitoches Parish schools have struggled for years with lackluster performance. We are a rural parish with many of our families mired in poverty, often for many generations. We are wracked with divisions of race and class. Good jobs and a growing economy continue to be elusive. A better school system is an indispensable first step.

The children have a right to an education. No one has a right to a teaching job. The education of the parish’s children is far too important for the status quo to continue. Our community is failing too many of our children. It is immoral. For all too many of our children, their teachers are all that stand between them and another generation of poverty and a stunted life. A teacher has to have many qualities to be successful. Before anything else, however, he or she needs to be well educated. Failure, particularly repeated failure, of a rudimentary test like the Praxis, gives me grave doubt as to one’s intellectual ability. I would not want such a person teaching my grandchildren, nor would I foist you on anyone else’s.

Raising the quality of the substitute pool is the quickest way to boost our system’s quality. Hiring long term substitutes who are not certified does not doom us to mediocrity. Quite the contrary, Natchitoches is not without resources. It is after all, a college town with a substantial retiree population. Let us look for indications of quality, something that shows a person has performed well on an objective standard at least as challenging as and, to be honest, quite a bit harder than, the Praxis.

Go to the head of the Louisiana Scholars’ College and ask her the following: Do you have any seniors who would like a challenging and worthwhile job before they go off to graduate or medical school? There are retirees who may want to be of use. There are any number of bright people in our community who may never have thought of teaching. It is time to fix that.