By Kevin Shannahan/Opinion

Up until recently, the Louisiana Legislative and Executive Branches wielded a near monopoly on what we shall charitably term a creative avoidance of reality in our state’s governance. While seldom in danger of being mistaken for the likes of John Marshall, Oliver Wendell Holmes or John Marshall Harlan, the upper reaches of Louisiana’s judiciary generally have not found new and inventive ways to embarrass our state. A recent decision by the Louisiana Supreme Court makes one wonder if they woke up one fine day and decided not to let the other two branches of government have all of the fun.
The case before the Louisiana Supreme Court involved a 24 year old man, far from a sympathetic defendant, accused of several sexual offenses with minors. He was interviewed twice at the police station where he eventually said:
“If y’all, this is how I feel, if y’all think I did it, I know that I didn’t do it so why don’t you just give me a lawyer dog cause this is not what’s up.”
That might not be the most eloquent statement to ever grace American jurisprudence, but anyone hearing or reading it would see it as a clear request for a lawyer with or without a comma after lawyer, dog or dawg.
The police continued questioning him. He then made several incriminating statements and now faces life in prison. His lawyer moved to suppress his statements on the grounds that the police continued to question him after he requested a lawyer. The motion was denied and the question went to the Louisiana Supreme Court which refused to hear the case.
A person being questioned by the police may invoke his right to a lawyer at any point in the interrogation. Questioning must then stop. The request must, however, be “clear and unequivocal.” Such statements as “Do I need a lawyer?” or “I might need a lawyer” have been found to not be an unequivocal request for counsel sufficient to invoke fifth and sixth Amendment protections. That was the prosecution’s claim, that the defendant did not make a clear request for a lawyer, a tortured line of reasoning if there ever was one. By a vote of six to one, the Louisiana Supreme Court agreed with them and declined to hear the case.
Associate Justice Crichton launched innumerable jokes at our state’s expense with his concurring opinion containing this memorable contribution to the legal canon: “In my view, the defendant’s ambiguous and equivocal reference to a “lawyer dog” does not constitute an invocation of counsel that warrants termination of the interview.” I suppose we should be grateful that the defendant did not express his desire for an attorney using coarser language. Instead of the mythical lawyer dog, the court would have declined to hear the case as a request for a lawyer having intimate relations with close female relatives did not constitute an invocation of counsel. One shudders to think of the jokes that opinion would have produced.
The court’s decision, or rather non-decision, required willful blindness to a plain reading of, or more to the point, listening to, the suspect’s statement. This isn’t some esoteric area of the law. The obligation of the police to stop an interrogation when a suspect invokes his right to counsel has been settled law for decades. I could understand the police getting caught up in the moment and continuing to question a suspect accused of some truly disturbing crimes. The courts, especially the state’s highest court, are supposed to stay above the fray.
I have read any number of comments on news accounts of the case that made fun of the defendant’s intelligence. Other, darker comments, carry on about Ebonics, Obama’s sons, and outright descents into racism. I have news for those people. This is not about him, it is about us. It is about all of us, black, white, brown, rich or poor. I am sure many of the commentators consider themselves staunch conservatives. I have news for them. They are not. Conservatism is not about unquestioning obedience to authority, but is about small government answerable to its citizens accompanied by a realistic view of the corrupting temptations of power. Conservatives should have a realistic view of human nature and a healthy distrust of governmental power.
The Bill of Rights to the Constitution stands between the citizen and the state. It is in the difficult areas that it is most necessary. Had the police taken the suspect out behind the station and beaten him, they would have done less damage to the rule of law than the Louisiana Supreme Court did with this silly mockery of a ruling.
Superbly written article. Whether one agrees or disagrees with the overall opinion, and I happen to agree…THIS is truth! “Conservatism is not about unquestioning obedience to authority, but is about small government answerable to its citizens accompanied by a realistic view of the corrupting temptations of power.“
Dead on the money…totally agree, this is as clear cut as it gets and they still got it wrong.
it is very important to rercognize these troubling issues – and hold accountant those who make these unlawful actions.