City Council denies St. Maurice Subdivision application a second time

UPDATE: Rhodes Attorney Issues Statement regarding this vote:

https://natchitochesparishjournal.com/2020/01/28/rhodes-attorney-release-statement-regarding-st-maurice-place-subdivision/

The Natchitoches City Council voted to deny an appeal from Rhodes Properties and Development at its meeting Monday night, Jan. 27. The appeal was for the Council to review a decision of the Natchitoches Planning and Zoning Commission at its Dec. 3 meeting that denied the application regarding the St. Maurice Subdivision. The Council voted to uphold the Commission’s decision, except for Council Member Sylvia Morrow.

The overall reasoning behind the decision was the preservation of the neighborhood’s character.

“Every homeowner has spoken to that [the character of the development] and that speaks volumes to me,” said Council Member Eddie Harrington. Several area residents spoke about their concerns for drainage, traffic congestion, the Rhodes’ trustworthiness, and decreasing property values.

Attorney Jared Dunahoe spoke for the Rhodes brothers. The gist of his argument was that after the Rhodes prior appeal was denied for its first application for the St. Maurice Subdivision project at a Council meeting on Sept. 13, the Rhodes brought everything into compliance with ordinances. They changed the design from a gated community to one on a public street with a 60 foot right-of-way instead of the initial 50 foot they had planned. The lots sizes (7,200 sq ft) meet the minimum required, although according to the Council many lots in the area are 20,000-21,000 sq ft on average. The new application also had one less house (27 lots) and the retention pond was removed.

Dunahoe said the changes Rhodes made before reapplying bring them in 100 percent compliance.

“Tonight’s decision is about will Natchitoches be a City that follows the rules…or will we move the goal post just to achieve a desired result. They’ve followed the rules and they should be allowed to continue with their project.”

Other agenda items included:

PLANNING & ZONING – FINAL:

Amend Ordinance No. 64 Of 2001 By Changing

Zoning Classification Of Property at 1504 Gold St. from R-3 Residence Multiple Family to R-3 Residence Multiple Family, Special Exception to operate Save the Children Head Start.

Amend Ordinance No. 64 Of 2001 By Changing

Zoning Classification Of Property at 219 Williams Ave. from R-1 Residential to R-1 Residential, Special Exception to operate a Bed & Breakfast.

2019 ORDINANCE – FINAL:

Authorize The City To Lease A Portion Of A Building Located At 200 Rapides Drive To Youth & Families Empowerment Services, LLC.

ORDINANCES – FINAL:
Approve The Acquisition Of The Hanger Located On Lot 3 Of The Natchitoches Regional Airport From Harold G. Foster And Laurie M. Berry, For The Consideration Of $13,000.

Amend Ordinance Number 042 Of 2019 Which Said Ordinance Approved The Acquisition Of A Tract Of Land Situated On The Western Right Of Way Of Sixth Street In The City Of Natchitoches, From Eagle Distributing Of Shreveport, Inc., For The Total Consideration Of $400,000.

Amend the 2019-2020 Budget to Reflect Additional Revenues And Expenditures.

ORDINANCES – INTRODUCTION:

Authorize The Mayor Of The City Of Natchitoches To Award The Bid For The Natchitoches Event Center Roof Replacement Project.

Authorize The Mayor Or His Designee To Advertise An Airport Hanger Lease For Maintenance Shop, Establishing The Terms And Conditions For Said Lease Which Will Include Obligation Of Lessee To Provide An Experienced Aircraft Mechanic And Aircraft Mechanics Shop For Fixed Wing And Rotor Wing Aircraft, Authorizing Mayor To Execute Lease After Due Advertisements And Compliance With Law.

RESOLUTIONS:

Authorize The Mayor To Execute A Certificate Of Substantial Completion To The Contract Between The City Of Natchitoches And Ratcliff Construction Company For The Natchitoches Sports & Recreation Park.

Authorize The Mayor To Enter Into Contract With Travelers Casualty And Surety Company Of America For The Public Official Schedule Bond For The City Of Natchitoches.

ANNOUNCEMENTS:

The next scheduled City Council meeting will be Monday, February 10, 2020.